Returning home to sell his late father's bookstore, the last thing Amish carpenter Jesse Kauffman expects is to be roped into a pretend romance ... with his childhood best friend. But Fannie Flaud is determined to shape her own future and will do anything to avoid the matchmaking plans of her well-meaning family. As they spend time together and rebuild their friendship, real feelings begin to grow between them. Now torn between Fannie and the life he planned in Indiana, Jesse must decide: Can he let go of his past to stay with the woman he's always loved?