It's the Comic Book Expo and Timmy wishes his favorite character, The Crimson Chin, into the real world. Before giving up all his old toys, Timmy wishes for one last chance to play with his Crimson Chin action figure. Timmy accidentally releases the evil anti-Chin into the real world, who then releases all other villians. Timmy hates his bath, to make matters worse, he's mistakenly brought in last month's issue of The Crimson Chin to read. Timmy's parents work so hard that by the time they get home, they're too pooped to do anything with Timmy.